Planing into ACDOCP: Options without BPC and SAC Licence

[Baschi]

Dear SAP Experts,

we want to offer a Financial Planing BI Solution for our customers in S/4 in order to plan into ACDOCP.

The challenge is:

• The classical "non ACDOCP " planing transactions (KP06, KEPM...) could be shut down in the near future. Is this assumption right?
• The functionality and user friendliness of the Fiori App "Import Financial Plan Data" does not match classical "non ACDOCP" planing transactions at which many customers are used to.
  https://fioriappslibrary.hana.ondemand.com/sap/fix/externalViewer/#/detail/Apps('F1711')/S14OP
  https://fioriappslibrary.hana.ondemand.com/sap/fix/externalViewer/#/detail/Apps('F1581')/S14OP
• The cost of BPC and SAC for Planing ACDOCP is too high for many customers.

Could you please recommend an ACDOCP planing BI Solution, which

• offers similar functionality to classical "non ACDOCP " planing transactions
• can be implemented easily
• is standard in S4 and does not Require BPC or SAC licences?

Thank you very much for your support!
Balazs

[former_member353197]

According to SAP Roadmap - BPC & SAC are the SAP planning solutions recommended from now on.
So I don´t believe that someone will recommend a non-SAP solution on a SAP Forum.

Regards,

[umessner]

Hello

my current customers are also interested in a simple standard Fiori App for Project Planning.

The available app "Import Financial Plan Data" might be ok for planning of multiple and complex projects. But thinking of very small projects and the requirement of changing e.g. just one simple value on one PSP element - especially after getting the information that SAP plans to replace internal orders by projects - they cannot understand why SAP does not offer an easier way.

So I would like to repeat the question again:

Could SAP please offer an ACDOCP planning solution which

• offers similar functionality to classical "non ACDOCP " planing transactions
• can be implemented easily
• is standard in S4 and does not Require BPC or SAC licences

Kind regards

U. Messner